The smell of Yalta in Munich

The smell of Yalta in Munich

18.02.2025, 09:57

President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said it well: 

"A peace agreement cannot be signed in Munich."
Because because it is Munich. The memory of Chamberlain's, as it turned out, insignificant piece of paper from Munich of 1938, which remained in the memory of generations who survived the Second World War, as a symbol of the war, as a symbol of an unsuccessful attempt to appease Hitler, was inevitable.

The speech of by US Vice President James Vance was a proclamation of a new American isolationism and nationalism. If there were any unknowns about the direction and rationale of the second administration's and the rationale for the second Trump administration's policies, they were certainly erased in front of a packed audience at the traditional Security Conference in the Bavarian city, which was receptive to the aggressive, caustic and cynical messages of the forty-year-old Ohio Republican with striking coldness and gloom. Deeply ideological, in a manner that has become recognizable both in style and content of the media platforms of the neoconservative and populist right, Vance's presentation is a a kind of indictment of the shaken Euro-Atlantic alliance.

The United The United States as we have known it is the largest and most important democracy in the world (despite all its mistakes, failures, and missteps in history) is no longer the one we we have known until recently, or, more precisely, that we have taken for granted.

Vice President Vance without reservation, expressing full conviction in what he was saying, issued a series of accusations and harsh assessments. His messages - although in some passages they went much lower passages, they went far below the minimum of decency in public communication regarding allied countries, were crystal clear. 

When it comes to Vance's conviction and and persuasiveness of Vance, even the greatest optimists and well-wishers do not not helped by the fact that this same man in 2016 called then-candidate trump an idiot "whose actions are reprehensible," and privately called him "the new "the new Hitler." We are now in a new reality, and Vance is at the top of a long list of new American officials and politicians for whom personal loyalty to Trump is the most important characteristic

Hopes, that the new anomaly will last only four years - as long as Trump is in the White House - is at best house is naive at best. It would be nice if such expectations were to be realized. History, however, has its own logic and dynamics, and it will not sit idly by and wait for the supposed end of Trump's term.

That's why vance's speech will remain in textbooks as the end of an era. Unity forged in the first and second global conflicts the first and second global conflicts, strengthened during the Cold War, is coming to an end with the de facto abandonment of Europe as a principled ally of the United States. Europeans face great challenges. French President Macron immediately realized this immediately realized this and urgently convened a meeting of the leaders of the leading European countries

American strategy without a strategy?

To the impression of a break with the Euro-Atlantic paradigm was truly complete and very and very disturbing, Trump's new Defense Secretary Pete Hagel, one of the faces of of the populist Fox TV channel, whose press conference on the occasion of the of NATO defense ministers, also exuded a forced self-assurance. Ghegseth in fact, had no clear and definitive answers to the question of possible/future negotiations to end the war, i.e. peace in Ukraine. This is not surprising either. Everything boils down to Trump's and his cabinet's and his cabinet's unquestioning, boundless trust in the negotiating abilities of the 78-year-old American president. 

"Everything is on the table" and "The President is the main negotiator the answers had to satisfy the journalists present, not only Ukrainian, but also ukrainian journalists, but also Hagseth's colleagues from allied countries. Trump's chief negotiator has already spoken with Vladimir Putin. Later, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy jokingly told the audience later jokingly told the audience in Munich. Irony and humor are also part of the the defense arsenal of brave Ukrainians

The main problem - apart from the stunning (even for Trump) rhetoric about the upcoming meetings and negotiations, which "in passing" mentions possible territorial "agreements" that would formalize Russia's occupation of eastern Ukraine and Crimea - was eventually confirmed by the Assistant to the President and Special Representative for Keith Kellogg, Assistant to the President and Special Representative for Russia and Ukraine

"EU representatives will not participate in the talks


This was a wake-up call for the entire EU. Marginalization, that's what it is. Alienation of Europe is the essence of Trump's new diplomacy. This leads to to negotiations dominated by commercial considerations. Europeans are not needed here europeans are not needed here, it is Putin who needs to be negotiated with, and something needs to be sold or given to Zelenskyy for his signature. To this end, at a bilateral meeting in Munich, the Ukrainian president was presented to the Ukrainian president at a bilateral meeting in Munich with a document stipulating that huge amounts of Ukraine's mineral wealth of Ukraine will be provided to the United States as compensation for military assistance since the

Volodymyr Zelenskyy refused to sign the text, which he had not read. This episode is deeply compromising for the United States - first of all because of the attempt, but also because it failed to to hide it from the international community. In the end, Ukraine will be ready to to compensate for at least part of the cost of weapons, ammunition and technology received from the West, if peace means the return of sovereignty over the occupied territories. It is also possible to have some kind of long-term international supervision, as well as the creation of a demilitarized zone, but recognition of Russia's conquests is excluded. V. Zelenskyy and the Ukrainian leadership simply cannot accept this

That is why kyiv's recognition of Russia's territorial conquests is out of the question. This "detail" reveals the inconsistency of the American position. Or, to put it better, an improvisation that cannot be hidden. Trump and his services, many of which are are being destructively "reformed" or simply eliminated by Elon Musk, which already "smells" of an inglorious end, are under serious Russian influence. And if you we consider this aspect, Vance's speech in Munich becomes even more important.

A new European policy?

Europeans are faced with a historic question. The departure of the United States - both in the ideological and and direct sense, as well as Washington's clear intentions to marginalize the EU and exclude it from political and from political and defense agreements is the biggest problem. To what extent this is insurmountable, we will find out very soon.

Right-wing populism and nationalism have weakened the EU and threatened it EU and have become a threat to it from within. Russia's harmful influence cannot be ruled out. The first political clash in this sense  occurs in Germany. The party "Alternative for Germany" (AfD), which, according to according to Vice President Vance, has become a kind of address for both meeting and for mentioning in his Munich speech, is a real threat to German democracy. The list of European countries where right-wing nationalists and populists are gaining popularity and influence right-wing nationalists and populists are gaining popularity and influence.
Miodrag VLAHOVICH

First Minister of Foreign Affairs of Montenegro (2004-06),

former Ambassador of Montenegro to the United States, Canada, Iceland and Rome

 


100 views

All article